Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Please explain...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Please explain...

    I just had a number of posts in a specific deleted without any discussion with me and their complete removal leaving no trace of their existence!

    I have participated in many forums for years and i have never seen posts removed without trace in this way, it reflects very badly on the forum.

    I am wondering whether perhaps in this forum the sponsors exercise undue influence on the moderators running the forum, as posts in response to mine by a sponsor reflected very poorly on the sponsor and were quite unprofessional.

    Because the posts were completely wiped without trace it leaves the impression that the sponsor was able to convince the owners of the site to cover up the sponsors behaviour and pretend like it never happened!

    I can understand the moderators or sponsor in this case deleting the details of his own posts, and even deleting my responses to him that could be deemed off-topic - but to delete all trace of all the original posts including my completely on-topic and relevant original post is something I have never seen on another forum.


  • #2
    Re: Please explain...

    yeah i saw that thread... you two brought it on yourselves....

    dont worry about it thems the rules

    you also need to understand that this forum is a commercial enterprise and is not owned by the "members" Andy owns it so its his rules. pretty simple

    we just have to suck it up if we have issues, or just leave easy as that.

    see last rule in highlight


    posting policy (the rules)
    http://coffeesnobs.com.au/YaBB.pl?num=1297317496/0#0


    CoffeeSnobs site sale policy notes.

    Sales
    * For members to sell their own excess 2nd hand equipment only (not sell for a friend etc).
    * Must have been a member for more than 2 weeks.
    * Must have posted 5 messages to the forums.
    * Use a full description of the item.
    * Need to include a selling price.
    * picture/s of the item while not required are advised.
    * Buyers are requested to note that the CoffeeSnobs Hardware for Sale area is not an auction site. If you are interested in an item, please contact the seller via PM.
    * If the item is being advertised elsewhere it will be removed from the forum.

    Wanted posts
    * Are only for second hand goods that members might have, not new items.
    * Must have been a member for more than 2 weeks.
    * Clearly mark the subject line with WTB or WANTED
    * These will be deleted when they are a week old.
    * Include the price range you are willing to pay

    No Commercial Posts in
    * Forum Posts
    * Signatures
    * Commercial Websites in Member Profiles

    CoffeeSnobs has a policy of no commercial postings unless authorised by the admin team.  Plugging your business (however subtle) will result in your account being blocked or removed without warning or notification.

    Links to ebay ads or other similar off-site promotion to any sales related material are not welcome on CoffeeSnobs.  If you would like to be included in the “Official Sponsor” list please contact me by email (not PM).  


    As always on the CoffeeSnobs forums we will exercise our right to delete first and ask questions later.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Please explain...

      Originally posted by 606C656868610D0 link=1297317496/1#1 date=1297318184
      yeah i saw that thread... you two brought it on yourselves....

      dont worry about it thems the rules

      you also need to understand that this forum is a commercial enterprise and is not owned by the "members" Andy owns it so its his rules. pretty simple

      we just have to suck it up if we have issues, or just leave easy as that.

      see last rule in highlight


      posting policy (the rules)
      http://coffeesnobs.com.au/YaBB.pl?num=1297317496/0#0


      CoffeeSnobs site sale policy notes.

      Sales
      * For members to sell their own excess 2nd hand equipment only (not sell for a friend etc).
      * Must have been a member for more than 2 weeks.
      * Must have posted 5 messages to the forums.
      * Use a full description of the item.
      * Need to include a selling price.
      * picture/s of the item while not required are advised.
      * Buyers are requested to note that the CoffeeSnobs Hardware for Sale area is not an auction site. If you are interested in an item, please contact the seller via PM.
      * If the item is being advertised elsewhere it will be removed from the forum.

      Wanted posts
      * Are only for second hand goods that members might have, not new items.
      * Must have been a member for more than 2 weeks.
      * Clearly mark the subject line with WTB or WANTED
      * These will be deleted when they are a week old.
      * Include the price range you are willing to pay

      No Commercial Posts in
      * Forum Posts
      * Signatures
      * Commercial Websites in Member Profiles

      CoffeeSnobs has a policy of no commercial postings unless authorised by the admin team.  Plugging your business (however subtle) will result in your account being blocked or removed without warning or notification.

      Links to ebay ads or other similar off-site promotion to any sales related material are not welcome on CoffeeSnobs.  If you would like to be included in the “Official Sponsor” list please contact me by email (not PM).  


      As always on the CoffeeSnobs forums we will exercise our right to delete first and ask questions later.
      Yeah, I read that thread too and the exchange reflected very poorly on the sponsor in question so I can understand why theyd want it removed. Yeah, its not great form but this is not a level playing field either. Those that pay for the site are paying for positive press. If their conduct is less than polite then for PR purposes they would want that rectified. Wouldnt you? Im sure all 13000 read the exchange and I for one was most impressed by the non-Americanised spelling. We have two choices here, behave or begone. Ill be good for now... Good luck!

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Please explain...

        As the sponsor concerned, it reflected poorly on both parties and I was surprised to see such vitriol on CoffeeSnobs. We dont do that here.

        Im disappointed that it came to that but am pleased that a thread that was well off topic is now back on topic.

        Im more than happy to apologise- and eat my hat if offence was caused, but bad language is out of line, whatever the context.

        We live in a time where we receive consistent attacks on price from members of the public who too often have an incomplete understanding of the costs of doing business in Australia. Incessant and one-sided attacks ultimately wear you down- especially with incorrect information and Im the first to admit the fuse is getting a tad short on this issue. I am over the sniping. :

        Guys, if you want a price, ask. If you want to discuss pricing, ask. Theres nothing wrong with manners. 

        Chris

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Please explain...

          That response shows exactly why whole posts and any record of them shouldnt be deleted - now a different spin can be put on what happened and what was posted and no one other than those that saw the thread will be any the wiser.

          Far better to have left the on-topic posts and just removed the off-topic inappropriate posts from the sponsor, and my replies to them.

          I guess I have had it made patently clear that this is not a public forum, but rather a commercial advertising site and should I choose to continue to post I will just have to accept that.

          Originally posted by 47727F784C507C75757676130 link=1297317496/3#3 date=1297319454
          Guys, if you want a price, ask. If you want to discuss pricing, ask.
          As you well know, thats exactly what I did. Seeing I got no help here i managed to source the Australian distributer and contact them directly.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Please explain...

            well when you buy one be sure to post pics and give us your review they are a sweet looking machine

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Please explain...

              As maheel said, coffeesnobs is a commercial enterprise and Andy sets the rules, but we dont necessarily have to suck it up if all/many members dont like something - part of running a business is responding to feedback received and I have a hunch that Andy would take the user communities views seriously. If you feel Andy needs to be made aware of something, the best thing is to email him directly as he doesnt always read every thread.

              I have to say though that the posts you refer to did seem to be getting a touch personal and while the mods may have removed one or two more than strictly necessary, I dont think they were being unreasonable.

              In general, I dont find the commercial nature of coffee snobs overly intrusive and the forums are lively and useful.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Please explain...

                Galumay, I too was surprised.
                I actually responded to one of your posts (prior to removal) offering some alternative advice, shame to see that my post was also removed along with yours

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Please explain...

                  I read the exchange and I dont think that the removal of the posts is worth crying about. Life goes on yeah?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Please explain...

                    Well there is 2 posts at polar opposites...

                    How long before this thread gets shut down?

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Please explain...


                      Im curious...which mod deleted the posts? Usually there is evidence of the removal in the thread?

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Please explain...

                        Originally posted by 79677F7264677C7D130 link=1297317496/10#10 date=1297759447
                        Im curious...which mod deleted the posts?  Usually there is evidence of the removal in the thread?
                        How is that relevant sniff?

                        The CS Admin Team which includes we Mods, all work within a consultative environment under the guidance and auspices of the Site Owner - Andy Freeman. None of us operate in isolation and we all work hard at maintaining the CS Forum to the high standards that it is well known for and appreciated by the vast majority of the membership.

                        As we all know, you cant please everyone all of the time but we sure work hard at trying to do exactly that.....

                        Mal.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Please explain...

                          Originally posted by 6B46424E432F0 link=1297317496/11#11 date=1297775422
                          Originally posted by 79677F7264677C7D130 link=1297317496/10#10 date=1297759447
                          Im curious...which mod deleted the posts?  Usually there is evidence of the removal in the thread?
                          How is that relevant sniff?

                          The CS Admin Team which includes we Mods, all work within a consultative environment under the guidance and auspices of the Site Owner - Andy Freeman. None of us operate in isolation and we all work hard at maintaining the CS Forum to the high standards that it is well known for and appreciated by the vast majority of the membership.

                          As we all know, you cant please everyone all of the time but we sure work hard at trying to do exactly that.....

                          Mal.
                          May be. But I definitely sense a conflict of interest at times between being both a moderator and a sponsor.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Please explain...


                            Usually when a thread goes off topic a mod moves the OT part to a new thread - which is entirely appropriate. It means the original thread can stay on topic.

                            Heated debate can often arise on this forum - which is all part of the coffee passion.

                            I sympathize with Galumay in that in my professional life I have seen similiar things done, where certain portions of transcript are taken out of context and then put in a new light.

                            However I also commend Chris on taking the opportunity to apologise.

                            The benefit in a mod posting "off topic replies have been moved to this topic" is that the reader can choose whether or not to follow the off topic thread, or continue reading the original post.

                            This thread seems to have been started to ask that mod to explain why the posts were deleted and not moved to an OT thread.

                            That hasnt happened. Thats why its relevant.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Please explain...

                              Sniff, the way I see it, there was a debate about what constitutes "courteous behaviour". At least one of those posts included some distasteful name-calling.

                              I think deleting part of these posts would have removed the context, and moving them to a separate thread wouldnt be productive.

                              Im glad theyre gone, and am also glad we have a Mod Team that are helpful and keep this forum an environment that people can enjoy.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X