Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Kaldi, home roaster ??

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Kaldi, home roaster ??

    Has anyone seen or tried the Kaldi home roaster ?

    Click image for larger version

Name:	137893-300.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	47.8 KB
ID:	756471
    Its a manual stovetop drum roaster that has shown up on Ebay,
    Has a 120mm dia drum , capacity 250gms, and a thermometer built in.
    Priced at $250 and made from all stainless and copper it seems a rival for the other mini drum roasters .

    EDIT
    I see they have a motorised drum drive version for $450 also
    Click image for larger version

Name:	137894-1.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	377.7 KB
ID:	756472

  • #2
    Adorable!

    But the one I found sold the trier and hopper separately.

    There Is Extra Charge For Hopper and Probe Rod
    Hopper=$45.00, Probe Rod=$15.00
    Did a quick youtube search, can't find anything. I'd love to see it in action...

    Comment


    • #3
      mmmm shiny, keen to hear how it performs.

      Comment


      • #4
        I'm confused as to how it dumps the beans?

        Comment


        • #5
          Well, there's that 1 hole. Probably used for everything...

          The more I thought about it, if there are no design flaw, this should stand above and beyond the baby roaster. Similar batch size, cheaper, and most importantly air flow. Might be smoky though. IMHO, just judging it from the pictures.

          Comment


          • #6
            The baby roaster is a well designed, well built and proven roaster. It was designed as a sample roaster and learning tool. It is sold and distributed by a reputable and extremely knowledgeable company, that has provided a great deal of advice about its use and techniques.
            This unit has potential, but is unproven.
            Also build quality is uncertain.
            Resale value, if not to your liking; probably ziltch.
            I would not touch it, sight unseen.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Bosco_Lever View Post
              I would not touch it, sight unseen.
              Chill, brah. Didn't mean to offend. As I said, if there are no design flaw.

              Haven't seen any pictures of the insides, will the flame directly hitting the beans? how fast the temp can be drop? airflow control? is it possible to add fan on the hopper for airflow control?

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by kutis View Post
                Chill, brah. Didn't mean to offend. As I said, if there are no design flaw.

                Haven't seen any pictures of the insides, will the flame directly hitting the beans? how fast the temp can be drop? airflow control? is it possible to add fan on the hopper for airflow control?
                Not offended.
                As you said, no pictures of the insides. No video of how it works. Location of flame in relation to the drum is very important. As you need to use a portable camp stove, this aspect will be important in determining roast times.
                Build quality is hard to determine.
                Seller is just a reseller. If actual info from the manufacturer was available, it would help with the decision making.
                Batch size is small, so for the money and risk, there are better, proven alternatives.

                Comment


                • #9
                  at $450 is it on par with a behmor?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by don_nairn View Post
                    at $450 is it on par with a behmor?
                    Pricing (ex postage) seems comparable, but would be very though to beat Andy after sales service, got my queries on behmor plus sorted in no time flat, well instantaneous response is slight exaggeration, just slight

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Bosco_Lever View Post
                      As you said, no pictures of the insides. No video of how it works. Location of flame in relation to the drum is very important. As you need to use a portable camp stove, this aspect will be important in determining roast times..
                      To be fair, there are plenty of pictures and descriptions of the drum, material (options for direct flame etc) for anyone who bothered to look.
                      Camp stove ?, why not stove top, fine flame adjustment and use the fume hood for extract !
                      just seems like a simple ( no controls etc to fail) , manual roasting drum....probably a bit too shiny and overpriced !

                      My preferance would be this one at only $90 complete with the electric drum drive !
                      Click image for larger version

Name:	674034294_845.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	51.6 KB
ID:	737566

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by blend52 View Post
                        To be fair, there are plenty of pictures and descriptions of the drum, material (options for direct flame etc) for anyone who bothered to look.
                        Camp stove ?, why not stove top, fine flame adjustment and use the fume hood for extract !
                        just seems like a simple ( no controls etc to fail) , manual roasting drum....probably a bit too shiny and overpriced !

                        My preferance would be this one at only $90 complete with the electric drum drive !
                        [ATTACH=CONFIG]6903[/ATTACH]
                        I did bother having a look and stand behind my comments.
                        Obviously you have never used a baby roaster, or similar unit, hence you would not be recommending stove top over a camp stove. (And indoor roasting)

                        "Just seems" is an assumption. You know what happens when you assume.

                        No antagonism intended.

                        As you said, it does have potential. I don't think much of your $90 option either.

                        I have used a baby roaster for almost four years, and after a while you understand what it is capable of. I doubt the Kaldi will be able to replicate the result. In browning ability, yes; but not in flavour.

                        I also question why anyone would want direct flame onto coffee beans?????. It comes with a copper tube to slide over the mesh to provide an "imitation" of a drum roaster, but I can see many flaws with the setup.

                        People are free to purchase if they want, but as I said, there are many proven alternatives.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Hello, here are some videos and pictures of Kaldi roaster:

                          motorises version



                          manual version



                          http://blog.naver.com/tm1010/220013036124

                          http://blog.naver.com/tm1010/220006200253

                          http://blog.naver.com/jirisan72/20209387063

                          Please, what can you recommend for home roasting beginner? The Kaldi or FZ RR 700 baby roaster? Thank you, Alex
                          Last edited by Javaphile; 19 July 2014, 02:11 AM. Reason: Fix link(s)

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I think comparing the kaldi and baby roaster is really an apples and oranges kind of issue.

                            Many people on this thread seem to be trying to get a good bargain, and you're welcome to do so (if not encouraged) but you cannot then jump to the conclusion that they can knock roasters like the hottop and behmor out of the market- let alone the baby roaster without even having any hands on experience with the new roasters. In principle they sound great, but when all is said and done, you really still do get what you pay for.
                            I'd say it is dangerous to speak highly of any appliance and quickly say they might outdo a known appliance in the same category purely based on 'specifications' ; especially when it retails for less than half of the other - we've already seen this happen with many other roasters before this one and I have my doubts on this one.

                            That said, this looks interesting and id be pleasantly surprised if it does perform similarly to other small batch roasters like the behmor or baby roaster.
                            The next question to ask then is how durable is this thing and how experienced is the person doing the review?

                            Just my 2 cents

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Capoeira View Post
                              Hello, here are some videos and pictures of Kaldi roaster:

                              [snip]

                              Please, what can you recommend for home roasting beginner? The Kaldi or FZ RR 700 baby roaster? Thank you, Alex
                              Thanks!

                              For beginner, baby roaster, no contest. Beginners need helps and information, with the baby, they'll get a lot of those, enough to be confused.

                              It looks very DIY, not as flushed as I thought it would be. It's very adorable though, like how the thermometer spins around with the manual handle.

                              Personally, the fact that it need to be man-handled at the end of the roast I know it's not for me. I've touched enough espresso machines. With that, it's just 2nd degree burn waiting to happen. And as an apartment dweller, I'll never be able to handle that smoke.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X